The standard menu includes some of our favorites, but with a unique assortment of ingredients within. For example, the chocolate chip cookie includes coconut and sea salt. The menu changes daily with about 12 cookies on hand at all times. Some of the other options include cookies and cream, maple bacon, oatmeal scotch, sch'mores, peanut butter banana crunch, peanut butter cup, red velvet, and white chocolate cherry. There are two gluten-free options; lemon poppy and sweet corn.
There are seasonal flavors along with their traditional favorites; for Fall our options were caramel apple crisp, candied yam, blueberry cobbler, carrot cake and pumpkin spice. The cookies come in 3 sizes - Schmall (a bite-sized option), Old-Fashioned (traditional style) & Schmack Snack (dee-dish). There were also brownies, macaroons and bars that looked equally awesome, but we stuck with the Sch'mores cookie since that's their signature item and the guy at the counter said that's one of his faves.
The cookie base was graham cracker, and it had a layer of chocolate topped with toasted marshmallow. The cookie portion tasted a bit dry, and the chocolate was underwhelming. I felt that $2.75 was kind of overpriced for what it was. But, it IS Times Square, and everything is double what it should be. I would go back to try a different cookie and give it a second chance, since we did wait hours to actually try it and the marshmallow had solidified, but based on my original experience, I wouldn't put this high on my priority list of places to try.
Schmackery's is open Sunday-Tuesday 8am-11pm; Wednesday-Saturday 8am-midnight.
362 W 45th Street off of 9th Ave
